Another Lesson in Cultural Differences, and This Time I Mean CULTURAL Differences
Image via Wikipedia
There are some things I always put on my must-do lists and there are things that disappoint me just because I feel the need to put them on the must-do list.
However there is always a bright side to a bad experience and most likely in my case that bright side will reflect some newly acquired insight into the culture I’m currently exploring. Sometimes it will just confirm a well recognised fact about that culture, but I will still be forced to welcome it as a revelation, since I have obviously been silly enough to expect something else instead.
The fabulously revealing experience I have had the pleasure of it hitting me straight on in the forehead yesterday was that of encountering the attitude embedded in the New York City Ballet.
If I am in a city with a relatively long ballet tradition and if that ballet house has trademark show for the season during which I’m visiting I have to put that show on my must-do list. Since it’s December in New York, my husband and I decided to start off the merry month with The Nutcracker. Yes I know a very stereotypical holiday thing to do but hey, the piece was first staged a hundred years ago , which means that for once America is only 50 years behind with the first staging of the NYC ballet’s nut-cracking performance going as far back as 1954’, which considering the circumstances is an honorable age for a show (try not to think we’ll soon be half a century away from the sexual revolution of the sixties…as you will experience a sudden attack of melancholy and the feeling you must make an appointment with your estetista as soon as possible to start removing those signs of aging).
To cut the long story short, we had a lovely night out and have as intended had the opportunity to peek into those well nourished cultural voids that define the frightening space in-between our European background and the American reality around us. Thanks to my most significant other we had seats in the front row of the second balcony. Yes I like the balcony better than the stalls and prefer to sit there if possible. Naturally the seats on the balcony must be front row if possible and it should not be one of the side rows. Straight on and with a bit of creator’s perspective is how I like my theater. The good thing about the balcony seats we had yesterday was that we had (naturally) nobody in front of us, but had a typical (and I do mean very typical) family behind us. But I’m getting ahead of myself.
Where I should really start this story is pure marketing . The much advertised and much visited performance hall in Lincoln center offers payable show-character-photo-ops, merchandising, snacks and sodas as well as a fancy-wannabe champagne island in the lower foyer. The problem is, that for some reason the institution feels that in a city, where you can pay your way through anything with a credit card, they have for some very elusive reason a better chance at getting the money from their customers if they do stuff cash only and tell you there is an ATM just at the other side of the street (never mind the rain). The second thing you encounter and is already making you feel a bit strange is the senior-citizen-volunteer system, which you have forgotten about. I’m still feeling very confused about all that. Less confused in theaters than in galleries but still wondering at every show if that is the best choice of staff in case of an emergency or in case one should communicate things quickly, efficiently and with respect. I give them credit for patience. But that’s probably as far as I’m willing to support this system until someone gives me more info to chew on.
Anyhow. . The show featured a large cast of ballet dancers, some thirty of them children taking ballet lessons at an affiliate ballet school. The orchestra was decent, did an awfully correct job on the Tchaikovsky but non the less started to leave the pit as soon as the last note was played.
Image via Wikipedia
The show itself was heavily overproduced with an enormous x-mas tree and well executed set solutions. Even the snowstorm looked rather impressive. However the tem in charge of the lightning must have gone for a break and left the work lights on, since there was honestly close to zero input on their side. So a bit of magic was lost due to a blunt absence of any proper atmospheric light in contrast with soft but determinant accents one would expect in such a production, and I dare say the set designer had in mind when putting it all together. The rest of the magic was subjected to step by step mutilation by (this is not going to sound nice) the chord of elephants that call themselves ballerinas. The stomping of the little feet was loud enough to punch holes in the floor. The gracefulness gave way to hysterical movement in panic to keep up with the pace of the music. Lack of training, coordination and general agility (apart from a well executed spectacularly received split!?!) added to the effect of a school performance. And for the male dancers, I have never ever seen characters so absorbed in their own reflections before in my life ( and mind you I worked in the biz). Dancing in pair seemed to take a special effort and even that did not help the leading couple as the ballerina was left to loose balance, while her partner was more or less fixing his hair. However the audience went wild at every broadway-ish trick in the show and clearly decided to treat the music as they have learned from film. And this last thing was the core of my discovery.
When you bring a culture up on a Hollywood diet, you get direct consequences in life as well as in the attitude towards other forms of cultural production. The
Image by gretchen robinette via Flickr
sub-ordinance of music was never yet so strong as here. Tchaikovsky was treated as film music is – a source of suspense, a welcoming shower, a little bit of romance and most of all as something not worth the attention it dares to take with the overture to each act. Coinciding with that the audience had a very different set of clapping interruptions that we usually experience in Europe and by the second act I felt I was in a circus. Obviously there’s nothing more mysterious or difficult then how to act at a concert, an opera or a ballet show…Yes and people brought food to the hall. Luckily it was only the annoying 3 kids, 2 parents and a nanny that hits children because she is running out of control the whole time, while mom and dad are quietly approving the behaviour of all parties. The family itself looked very civilised, they even dressed up the kids in very serious outfits. They just forgot to tell them how to behave and what the heck they were doing at this theatre anyhow. So the kids got 0 magic, the parents got a headache, and the nanny probably got fired as did so many before her that just could not tame the southern accent of the spoiled brats. Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for bringing bot h parent s and children to shows like this. Both could learn a lot. The problem of Nutcracker in this environment was, that neither did the children want to consume a high culture thing and were so against it they almost did not see any part of the story that was not directly related to the merchandising they saw before entering the hall, neither did the parents take time to get themselves reminded of the true
Image via Wikipedia
message the Nutcracker is trying to get across. The message spelling out the potentials holiday season has in motivating, igniting and nourishing the vivid imagination of young ones, of the wonderful world that can take place under the decorated tree in a land where soldier toys come alive to fight with the mice and candy canes dance when you become the special guest in the kingdom of dreams.
Overall the all white performing cast (which i found horribly strange in the middle of New York) made the highly predominantly white audience (and I took a really good look at the audience) happy. There were no reasons for refunds and the show goes on. Money in, money out. The system works without the artistic surplus. So why bother getting better if this is good enough.
http://www.naxos.com/education/enjoy2_concertmanners.asp

![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=1d0d1c99-e028-4b1f-947f-1ddf14cd423c)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=a7831ad3-b9f7-41e6-bbe8-3ab61605078c)

![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=af049473-b60a-41fc-8f47-f69b8d429d81)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=667ecc52-bbaf-475e-a7ea-34df9c5e8b37)


